I’m just typing out loud. Battlestar Galactica stuff, ignore freely. I want to come back and look at what I was thinking next year, when the series ends. This is very much spoilery, so if you watch BSG and haven’t caught up, or don’t want my speculation to ruin the show for you, stop reading now.
Thought #1: Ron Moore claims that “The Final Cylon” is not any of the people who appear in the “Last Supper” picture. Only three of the four we already know are pictured, however. So, if Ron is playing semantic games, the final-unknown-cylon could in fact be present in the picture while the “final cylon” in this case would be the one we do know who was absent from the shoot.
Thought #2: D’Anna/Three claims that only four of the “Final Five” are with the human fleet. The obvious has already been beaten to death (fifth is dead and Three knows it; fifth is with the Cylons; Three is lying; fifth is not with either fleet), but the “How would she know?” and “Is that good writing?” questions trump most things (including the possibility of her lying).
So, Adamas (even the dead ones) and Roslin would be poor writing. Unless “Thought #1″ is correct (and I believe it is incorrect), they and also Starbuck/Gaius are out (and too obvious and thus boring writing). Ellen (although interesting) would undermine a whole lot of good writing. Everyone obviously interesting is either in the picture, with the human fleet or certainly not “hungering for redemption”.
I was babbling to Laurie about all this, and how the only available bigger “reveals” for the final cylon are universally stupid or contradict “what we know”. And what do you know, but she managed to identify the one presumably-dead person that fits, that blew my entire mind and is all kinds of interesting: Socrata Thrace, Kara’s mother. Leoben knows far too much about Socrata, and considers Kara far too important, for her to be just another meaningless human.
All the other theories I’ve read are stupid, so I’m sticking to this one.
Besides, Asimov already did the “Robot Waiting in the Moon for Humanity’s Return” bit, so here’s hoping BSG doesn’t decide to rip him off in this fashion.
Thought #3: Either “that ain’t Earth”or, even if it is, it isn’t the final destination. Easy enough to explain why: Roslin isn’t dead yet. I’m unclear as to why we haven’t given her another shot o’ cure-all miracle baby blood (Maybe “God, what were we thinking when we wrote that stupid plot twist?”). Of course, Socrata’s mother died of a “wasting disease” and has certainly “lead” humanity to “Earth”, so keep Thought #2 in mind, huh huh huh.
Thought #4: “AND THEY HAVE A PLAN”… Yes, and? I guess it’s the cylons-behind-the-cylons who have The Plan? I hope that gets resolved, because…
Thought #5: …you do not under any circumstance forgive and embrace the machines who exterminated many billions of your people, reducing your entire civilization to nothing. I assume the non-rebel Cylons will be positioned to take the punishment/justice for this, but this aspect of the storyline, like so much that involves Lee, is farcical, even if it was or will be demonstrated to have been a form of “payback”.
That’s plenty for now. Socrata!!!